Komentar

How realistic are China's plans in Afghanistan?

China’s newly-found enthusiasm to replace the United States in Afghanistan is not without some bluster. Contrary to the perception it projects as the Asian giant out there to play the arbiter of peace in the central- and south-Asian region, China is unsure of the practicability of its economic or strategic objectives in the war-torn country. Even the feeling of relief that the shadow of rival United States has finally abandoned the country may not be genuine.

17.09.2021 23:36
Piše: Valerio Fabbri
Ključne besede:   Valerio Fabri   China   Afghanistan   Pakistan   Talibans   Uygurs   Belt and Road Initiative   Asia   Europe   Beijing

Photo: Twitter

The Talibans are interested in having China on their side for two reasons – financial aid and recognition of their government.

On August 17th, two days after the Talibans formally claimed power in Kabul, the Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson, Hua Chunying, lambasted the United States more than the Talibans: "Wherever the US sets foot, be it Iraq, Syria or Afghanistan, we see turbulence, divisions, broken families, deaths and other scars in the mess it has left. The US power and role are destructive rather than constructive."

 

It goes without saying that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is acutely aware that without serious security commitments there is no possibility of interventions in other countries yielding concrete results. China is certainly not willing to put soldiers on the ground in Afghanistan. However, Bejing has to contend with the fact that to achieve superpower status without projecting its military might is a difficult task. The Americans may come into Afghanistan uninvited and exit in haste, but there is no denying that China enjoyed the veneer of stability that the American military presence ensured in Afghanistan.

 

Its security concerns about the Uyghur Muslim "extremists" using Afghanistan to disturb the Xinjiang province nearly evaporated in all the 20 years of the American presence in Afghanistan. Having the United States disappeared from the picture, who will step into those shoes with enough military might to command stability inside the country? The CCP has no real answer to that. It must rule itself out because it is not interested in a military commitment, one of the main reasons for which China is suddenly realizing the benefits of a multi-lateral approach to the Afghan crisis. It has its all-weather ally Pakistan, Russia and former CIS nations all roped into a loose group in order to have the comfort of numbers. The underlying, overarching interest of all these countries is to exploit the economic opportunities that an unstable Afghanistan, rich in natural and strategic resources, presents.

 

A closer scrutiny, however, reveals some fallacies. It is an overstatement to claim that China wants to exploit Afghanistan’s massive mineral wealth. Deep mining contracts in the country’s inaccessible terrain are long-term projects which, should they become reality, will tie up billions of dollars for years together. China’s first attempt to grab a big mining contract in Afghanistan has turned into a disaster. In 2007, China secured a 30-year lease for two of its companies to mine and smelt copper from the Mes Aynak mine outside Kabul. The mine is said to have ore worth $88 billions, and the copper is supposed to be of a high grade. Over a decade has gone by and the mine has not yielded even an iota of the billions of dollars China has sunk in so far.

 

Intent on expanding its economic ambitions, China failed to consider the logistical nightmares in Afghanistan – the government could provide no road networks, no coal for the power plant, no infrastructure facilities of any other kind. Another topic of contention, for which China creates much hype, is a narrow corridor called the Wakhan Corridor, that connects Afghanistan and China across a 47-mile stretch. In its public entreaties to the Talibans, China has repeatedly asked them to make sure that Uyghur Muslims do not use this region to enter Xinjiang and spread unrest. The reality is that the terrain is difficult in normal times and inaccessible during winter, so any encroachers can easily be spotted by the Chinese army personal on guard. Rather, the threat from Uyghur factions, in terms of radicalisation of Uyghur youth, is likely to come from Pakistan.

 

 

"The Talibans are interested in having China on their side for two reasons – financial aid and recognition of their government."

 

 

Needless to say, China is looking at some long-term projects in Afghanistan that are tailor-made for achieving its objective of expanding its influence via Asia to Europe through the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Tajikistan, which borders with both countries, has four border crossings with the Badakshan province in Afghanistan. They are the most popular haulage routes between China and Afghanistan. The Talibans control these crossings, which are also secured by security forces from China, Russia and Tajikistan. It is possible that this stretch of the trans-national route can be expanded to increase trilateral trade, but this won’t happen before sometime in the future. The other project that interests China is about extending the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor to Kabul that will stretch BRI connectivity from Afghanistan to China via Pakistan. 

 

All these projects are long-term commitments and cannot take off in the near future. The Talibans are interested in having China on their side for two reasons – financial aid and recognition of their government. They are willing to give any assurance that China wants, whether not sheltering Uyghurs or protecting China’s economic interests in Afghanistan, as they really cost them nothing. The leverage, if any, helps the Taliban more. When it comes to interests that matter to the Taliban – like their continued association with terrorist groups and giving shelter to them in Afghanistan -- they are unwilling to listen even to China.

 

That leaves China with Pakistan, an ally it has nurtured over the years. It is said to exercise control over Afghan affairs – terrorist or Talibani – through the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI). The one thing China will eventually do is lean on Pakistan to monitor the Taliban and ensure it does not go back to its 1996-2001 avatar. For all these reasons, China’s public utterances appear far removed from any strategic clarity on what it wants to do and achieve in Afghanistan.

 

Valerio Fabri is Ljubljana based Italian journalist. He writes for several international media outlets, including portal+.

KOMENTIRAJTE
PRIKAŽI KOMENTARJE
4
Evropa na razpotju: Zgodovinski izzivi in napačne rešitve
12
16.08.2022 22:10
Vojna v Ukrajini je razgalila resnico o Rusiji. Kdor ni želel opaziti, da se Putinova država nagiba k imperializmu, se mora ... Več.
Piše: Mateusz Morawiecki
Uredniški komentar: Če bi bil Trump ameriški predsednik, Putin ne bi razmišljal o Ukrajini
22
10.08.2022 23:45
Zakaj je Donald Trump lahko ključ do rešitve vojne v Ukrajini? Ker je nekonvencionalni politik z mentaliteto trgovca in ker je ... Več.
Piše: Dejan Steinbuch
Enotnost Evropske unije in Zahoda glede Ukrajine ogrožajo pozivi k "miru za vsako ceno"
18
05.08.2022 20:00
Februarja letos sem ob odločni in enotni reakciji Evropske unije na rusko invazijo na Ukrajino na tem mestu zapisal, da je ... Več.
Piše: Božo Cerar
Portret leve razvajenke: Ali sonce res vzhaja na vzhodu in zahaja na zahodu?
14
04.08.2022 20:00
Oseba, o kateri nameravam napisati nekaj opazk, je bila rojena v družini, ki po vseh lastnostih sodi v t.i. novi razred , kakor ... Več.
Piše: Denis Poniž
Roko na srce, Slovenci nimajo pojma, kaj so nevladne organizacije in civilna družba
10
03.08.2022 23:45
Strategi t.i. levice so že zdavnaj ugotovili, da jim ta nedorečenost okrog nevladnih organizacij in civilne družbe silno ... Več.
Piše: Miha Burger
Nepotrebno, škodljivo in populistično davčno maščevanje "bogatejšemu sloju"
16
02.08.2022 23:00
Vladni predlog kar štirih zakonskih sprememb na področju davkov, kar mediji ljubkovalno imenujejo davčna reforma, že na prvi ... Več.
Piše: Ivan Simič
Premierjeva čustva, neobdavčene denarne nagrade za gasilce in vsemogočni nevladniki
14
01.08.2022 22:00
Predsednik Golob, vseeno hvala za vaš trud. Uspeli ste opozoriti na potrebe gasilcev in to je dobro. Upam, da vam uspe ... Več.
Piše: Milan Krek
Evropska unija v svetu 21. stoletja bo morala spremeniti sistem odločanja, ali pa je čez desetletje ne bo več
7
24.07.2022 22:55
Povojno obdobje je svet upravljala skupina G7, v kateri so se znašle najrazvitejše države. V samo nekaj letih ali celo mesecih ... Več.
Piše: Iztok Mirošič
Genialni minister Loredan bi 18 mesecev delal stresni test zdravstva za pol milijarde evrov, največja slovenska občina pa je ponoči brez dežurnega zdravnika
15
24.07.2022 00:00
Minister za zdravje Danijel Bešič Loredan se je odločil in večkrat povedal celemu svetu, da bo v prvih 18. mesecih mandata s ... Več.
Piše: Milan Krek
Ne razumem ljudi, ki svoje življenje in svojo moč izkoriščajo za obtoževanje in uničevanje drugih
8
20.07.2022 20:00
Ne razumem posameznikov, ki jim visoke pozicije tako udarijo v glavo, da izgubijo razsodnost in namesto da bi svoje delo ... Več.
Piše: Ivan Simič
Loredanov zakon o interventnih ukrepih v zdravstvu ali kako bo Aleš Šabeder nadzoroval tri klonirane Šabedre
10
17.07.2022 22:45
Loredanov zakon prinaša tudi poseben urad, Urad za nadzor kakovosti in nabav v zdravstvu, ki naj bi med drugim nadziral ... Več.
Piše: Milan Krek
Duh stalinizma in rentgenska slika Ruske kapelice v globokem vesolju
26
16.07.2022 18:00
Levica, ki je trenutno na oblasti oziroma misli, da je, še vedno ni naredila domače naloge in preštudirala zgodovine zapletenih ... Več.
Piše: Dejan Steinbuch
Stop za avtokracijo: "Važna je vsaka gesta, vsaka beseda, vsaka akcija, da se prepreči avtokracija kjerkoli v svetu!"
15
12.07.2022 22:00
Dobro in koristno bi bilo, če bi vsak državljan sveta, ki ima idejo, kako zmanjšati možnost nastanka avtokracije, to tudi ... Več.
Piše: Miha Burger
Novi generalni direktor NIJZ Branko Gabrovec si je dal zlakirati tla v pisarni, da bo lažje plesal
15
11.07.2022 22:41
Ko sem si želel 4. julija, preden sem predal posle, še zadnjič ogledati svojo pisarno na Nacionalnem inštitutu za javno zdravje, ... Več.
Piše: Milan Krek
Obstaja veliko stvari, ki so pomembne v svobodni družbi. Izbira je ena izmed njih.
6
10.07.2022 22:00
O tem, kako pomembna je izbira, se po mojem mnenju premalo govori.Najbolj očitno je v ključni moči, ki jo imajo volivci pri ... Več.
Piše: Keith Miles
Urška Klakočar Zupančič je najšibkejši člen sedanje oblasti. Skrbi me zanjo.
27
06.07.2022 18:00
Janez Janša in njegovi verniki so bili neotesani, pa je narod raje dvignil pesti za Gibanje Svoboda. Robert Golob, predsednik ... Več.
Piše: Ana Jud
Pričevanje iz prve roke: Kako je bil Milan Krek prisiljen odstopiti kot generalni direktor NIJZ
26
04.07.2022 21:25
Seveda je moj odstop zoper vsa pravila vodenja, a tako pač je. Če se politika odloči, da moraš oditi, saj edino ona ve, kaj je ... Več.
Piše: Milan Krek
Prvih 100 dni vlade: "Ugrabljeni" premier, amaterski komunikatorji in naftna apokalipsa
12
28.06.2022 20:00
Ljudje bi lahko razumeli, da se zgodijo problemi z derivati, s sprejemanjem nepremišljenih predlogov zakonov in podobno, če jim ... Več.
Piše: Gregor Kos
Gospod premier, obljubili ste nam, da bomo živeli v svobodi in da nikogar ne boste maltretirali. Žal prvi tedni ne kažejo tega!
14
26.06.2022 21:35
Odstopil sem po imenovanju novega ministra za finance in to zaradi tega, ker imam svoj ponos in ne dovolim, da kdor koli ... Več.
Piše: Ivan Simič
Zdaj je jasno: Izvolili smo ljudi, ki ne sodijo v hram demokracije, ampak v kakšno zakotno špelunko ali zidanico
27
25.06.2022 21:48
Proslava ne more biti kronotop za razkazovanje nekega hudo poškodovanega ega, za zasebno poplesavanje in nasmihanje v slogu ... Več.
Piše: Denis Poniž
1 2 3 4 5  ... 

Najbolj brano

01/
Stari okostnjaki iz omar ljubljanske nadškofije se bojijo, da bi škof Saje začel čistiti cerkveno nesnago!
Uredništvo
Ogledov: 3.288
02/
Uredniški komentar: Če bi bil Trump ameriški predsednik, Putin ne bi razmišljal o Ukrajini
Dejan Steinbuch
Ogledov: 1.675
03/
Konec let debelih krav: Ali se je globalno načrtovani finančni cunami že začel?
Frederick William Engdahl
Ogledov: 1.155
04/
Pravoslavna verska vojna: Hudičev pakt med patriarhom Kirilom in predsednikom Putinom
Maksimiljan Fras
Ogledov: 1.246
05/
Protiamerikanizem in ruska propaganda v Grčiji
George X. Protopapas
Ogledov: 1.273
06/
Pro et contra: "Rusi bodo šli do konca, pa naj stane, kar hoče. Za ceno tretje svetovne vojne, če je treba."
Marko Golob
Ogledov: 3.876
07/
Portret leve razvajenke: Ali sonce res vzhaja na vzhodu in zahaja na zahodu?
Denis Poniž
Ogledov: 2.619
08/
Panika je odveč, dvigovanje obrestnih mer ne bo prav dosti obremenilo slovenskega proračuna
Bine Kordež
Ogledov: 881
09/
Evropa na razpotju: Zgodovinski izzivi in napačne rešitve
Mateusz Morawiecki
Ogledov: 535
10/
China's Communist Party holds cadres responsible for family members' activities
Valerio Fabbri
Ogledov: 608